Difference Between Tips and Service Charges
Tips are given voluntarily by customers to staff as a reward for the service they've received. This amount is discretionary here in the UK and not compulsory, unlike some other countries where, though also not compulsory, a certain percentage of the overall bill is usually added and left as a tip if the service has been good.
Tips are usually administered in one of two ways. The proprietor of the hotel, bar, pub or restaurant will either allow staff to collect tips individually or they'll be collected in what's known as a 'tronc'. This term derives from the French meaning 'collection box' often referred to in the UK as the 'tip jug'. In this scenario, the tips might have been intended for a specific individual but they will be required to place any tips in the tronc to be distributed amongst the staff at a later time. The tronc will be run by a member of staff (troncmaster) who is acting independently of the employer. If the company uses a tronc, it's for the troncmaster (who cannot be the employer or a director of the company) to stipulate how the tips are divided up. If the employer does not have any say on how the tips are shared out, then the tips are not subject to National Insurance (NI) contributions although they are still legally liable for tax which should be paid via the troncmaster if he/she is responsible for dividing and sharing the tips.
Service charges, on the other hand, are compulsory additions to the price charged for a service and, in the hospitality industry, they are usually between 10% and 15% of the total cost of the bill. These are collected by the employer and, if shared amongst the employees via the payroll, they are subject to both tax and NI.
Your situation may be slightly different. ask a question below ↓ and our editorial team will reply with our advice.
HM Revenue & Customs Implications
Many employers and employees are often guilty of 'overlooking' tips and gratuities when it comes to tax and NI and employees in particular often mistakenly view tips as a 'cash in hand bonus' to their wages. However, it's important to state that ignorance is no escape from the law and mistakes relating to this area can be very costly to an employer if investigated by HMRC and found to be a contravention of the law.
The key things to remember are that income tax is due on all tips, no matter how they are given. If tips are offered in cash from the customer directly to the employee, then the employee should declare them for tax purposes. If the tips come by way of being added to a bill paid for by credit card, then it's the employer's duty to declare them for tax.
If any tronc has not been formally registered with the Inland Revenue, then the business is responsible for deducting the tax and if it doesn't want to be liable for NI contributions too, it must ensure that it has no influence on the way by which the tips are divided. This can be done by holding a written record signed by the staff outlining how they themselves have decided to divide the tips.
The HMRC has recently revised its guidelines on tips and troncs and more detailed information can be found on its website or by obtaining the leaflet E24.
My former employer states if you leave within that 3 month period you forfeit your tips. Is this legal?
The 3 month period wAs September-end November and I questioned it as I left on November 17th less than 2 weeks off the 3 month period. I was told sorry you won’t get tips (of approximately £150) unless i work till the end of the month.
I've looked on ACAS and other websites and assuming that even though customers pay workers for their service, employers can just do what they want anyways? Renders the whole tips scheme useless. We have a tronc, but he's the GM and he says its going towards the printer.
I've been working at Everyman Cinema what works like a restaurant and bar, we serve food and drinks but you're watching a film. (Thought I explain if some people haven't heard of the company yet). Our venue is having a staff party and they'll be using tips money and won money from an upselling competition toward this event. Unfortunately I cannot make it due to family issues. I've talked to several managers about it and even mentioning that they're using our tips money all they said is they can't do anything about it and it's not their fault that I can't make it... Now if I'm well aware they can't keep the tips money from me as I'm a member a staff as well as the others. Is there anything I can do about it at all? Would very much appreciate any help. Thank you
also he did not gave any of this info when people start working for then. can he do this? is it legal?
thank you
A company I am working with at a few of the UK festivals says that all tips given will be paid to a local charty.
Is this even legal? Thought staff tips were for the staff? Presuming that the tips are actually being given to a charity that is...
Can I ask for proof of said tips actually being given to a charity?
Thanks
Please guide me is it justice or not . What is solutions without letting owner knew. Other wise they torture me by different means. Any legal help without any body knows. All are treated as same .same part timers
Regards
Lisa
In February this year our tips were witheld due to new guidelines which says tips must now be taxed. 10 months on we have just been paid the tips through payroll. This now has to be declared to tax credits and affects how tax credits are paid for some employees.
They have also stated that we won't be paid them again for another 12 months in a bid to stop us leaving.
Is this legal?
I work at a local bar/restaurant and none of the staff at work receive any tips. We all put the tips into a small pot (which is always in cash as we don't accept tips on card) and at the end of the night it is put in a locked box and afterwards is never seen again. They are suppose to get shared out between the staff but as far as we are aware our boss pockets it for himself. I have been there for over a year and never seen any of my tips and some others have been there longer. There are no signs telling customers that we don't receive them and if my boss found out we were warning customers I am sure he would probably be furious. My boss is the one in charge of the tips and the few who have gotten tips have had a hard time getting them having got into arguments with my boss to get them risking them their job. He has made it as hard as possible for them.
I need my tips as this would help a lot towards my university studies as I don't get much student finance and my parents can't help me out but I am unsure what to do as as far as I am aware there is now law to say my boss has to give me them and an argument with him seems very intimidating for me. Any advice?
Secondly can the employer stop staff receiving tips and instead treat them as a donation to the company or a charity? Thanks.
I work for a large restaurant chain that puts an optional 10% service charge on the bill. When a customer asks to remove this and tip us personally the management then take the 10% off and enter the amount given as a manual service charge. We have no tronc and at no point do we get any share of this money. They say it pays for staff food., even though we only get food on an 8 hour shift and they limit our shifts to 6 hour splits so we don't get any. As far as i knew if a customer chose to tip a wait personally it was classed as a gift therefore is it theft fir them to take it off us?
Ask Studentastic a question
Ask our editorial team a question and we will reply with our advice. Tell us as much about your situation as you can: the more detail you give, the more useful our answer can be.
You do not need to use your real name. Please do not include your full address, phone number, email address, or the names of other people. We may edit or remove identifying details for privacy and legal reasons.
Comments are moderated before publication.